Skip to content
macros vs calories - food quality vs calories

CALORIES, MACROS, OR QUALITY - WHAT MATTERS MOST?

DRXVE COMP Nutrition Method Small

You eat organic. You buy grass-fed. You avoid gluten. You meal prep every Sunday.

But you're still not losing fat.

Here's why: You're worrying about the wrong things in the wrong order.

Let me show you the hierarchy that actually matters.


 

THE ORDER OF OPERATIONS FOR FAT LOSS

When it comes to dropping body fat, there's a clear hierarchy:

1. CALORIES FIRST
2. MACROS SECOND
3. QUALITY THIRD

Not the other way around. Let me explain why.


 

#1: CALORIES ARE KING

You're not going to outwork the caloric deficit equation.

If you want to drop body fat, you need to be in a caloric deficit. Period.

Doesn't matter if it's organic, gluten-free, paleo, keto, or "clean." If you're eating more calories than you're burning, you're not losing fat.

The research is clear on this:

A 2007 study published in Obesity Research and Clinical Practice showed that "independently of the method for weight loss, the negative energy balance alone is responsible for weight reduction."1 Whether you cut calories through diet alone or diet plus exercise, the deficit is what drives fat loss.

The National Institutes of Health recommends a caloric deficit of 500-750 kcal/day for safe, sustainable weight loss of 0.5-1 kg per week.2 This isn't theory. This is thermodynamics.

You can eat organic, grass-fed, gluten-free everything and still not lose fat if you're not in a caloric deficit.

Calories are king. Everything else is secondary.


 

#2: MACROS MATTER (AFTER CALORIES)

Once you're in a deficit, your macros matter for two big reasons:

THE THERMOGENIC EFFECT OF FOOD

Your body burns calories digesting food. This is called the thermic effect of food (TEF).

Not all macros have the same thermogenic effect:

  • Protein: 20-30% of calories burned during digestion
  • Carbs: 5-10% of calories burned during digestion
  • Fats: 0-3% of calories burned during digestion

Translation: Eating more protein increases your metabolic rate.3

Getting more protein in your body helps your body burn at a higher metabolic rate. Your body works harder to break down protein, which means you're burning more calories just by eating it.

Fiber has a similar effect.

Your body has to work harder to break down fiber, which increases your metabolic rate and helps you burn more fat.4

PROPER FUEL BREAKDOWN

Your macros also matter because each macro serves a specific purpose:

PROTEIN:

  • Muscle building and recovery
  • Protects lean mass during fat loss
  • Highest satiety (keeps you full longest)

CARBS:

  • Energy for training
  • Brain function
  • Glycogen for performance

FATS:

  • Hormone production
  • Brain function
  • Inflammatory recovery
  • Vitamin absorption

Getting the right dosages of each matters. That's why we track macros.

But here's the key: Macros only matter AFTER you've handled calories.

You can have perfect macro ratios and still not lose fat if you're eating too much total food.


 

#3: QUALITY MATTERS (BUT NOT THE WAY YOU THINK)

Food quality absolutely matters. Don't eat junk all day.

Most junk food has:

  • Shit carbs (sugar, refined flour, low fiber)
  • Shit fats (trans fats, inflammatory oils)
  • Less micronutrients (vitamins, minerals)
  • More additives, pesticides, preservatives
  • Lower satiety (doesn't keep you full)

But here's the brutal truth:

You can eat organic, grass-fed, gluten-free, "clean" food all day and still not lose fat if you're not in a caloric deficit.

I've seen it hundreds of times:

  • The nurse eating "healthy" salads with 600 calories of dressing
  • The teacher meal prepping organic chicken but eating 3,000 calories daily
  • The professional buying grass-fed everything but never tracking total intake

Quality matters. But it can't outwork a caloric surplus.


 

THE COMMON MISTAKE: SKIPPING STEP 1

Here's what most people do:

They focus on Step 3 (quality) and ignore Step 1 (calories).

They buy organic everything. They avoid gluten. They meal prep with grass-fed meat and sweet potatoes.

Then they can't figure out why they're not losing fat.

Because they never created a caloric deficit.

You're solving for the wrong variable.


 

HOW TO APPLY THIS (THE RIGHT ORDER)

If your #1 goal is dropping body fat, here's what to do:

STEP 1: GET INTO A CALORIC DEFICIT

  • Track your food for 7 days (yes, even weekends)
  • Calculate your average daily intake
  • Create a 300-500 calorie deficit
  • Track consistently

Tool: We recommend Chronometer Pro. Here's our setup guide.

Deficit example:

  • Maintenance: 2,200 calories/day
  • Fat loss target: 1,700-1,900 calories/day

STEP 2: HIT YOUR MACROS

Once you're in a deficit, optimize your macros:

Protein priority:

  • 0.8-1.0g per pound of body weight
  • Protects muscle during fat loss
  • Increases metabolic rate
  • Keeps you full

Example for 150 lb person:

  • Protein: 120-150g daily
  • Carbs: 150-200g daily (adjust for training)
  • Fats: 40-60g daily

Learn more: The Macro Lens - How to See Food Composition

STEP 3: CHOOSE QUALITY FOODS WHEN YOU CAN

Within your calorie and macro targets, prioritize:

Better protein sources:

  • Lean meats (chicken, turkey, fish)
  • Greek yogurt, cottage cheese
  • Eggs
  • Whey protein

Better carb sources:

  • Rice (white or brown)
  • Sweet potatoes
  • Oats
  • Fruit
  • Whole grain bread

Better fat sources:

  • Olive oil (measured)
  • Avocado (measured)
  • Nuts (measured)
  • Fatty fish

More fiber:

  • Vegetables (peppers, broccoli, spinach)
  • Fruits
  • Legumes

But remember: Quality matters AFTER you've handled calories and macros.


 

THE REAL WORLD APPLICATION

Scenario 1: Fast food but in deficit

  • Eating Chipotle bowls daily
  • Tracking macros accurately
  • 300 calorie deficit maintained
  • Result: Fat loss happens

Scenario 2: Organic everything but no deficit

  • Eating organic, grass-fed, gluten-free
  • Never tracking total intake
  • Eating 2,500 calories at 2,200 maintenance
  • Result: No fat loss

Which scenario wins?

Scenario 1. Every time.

Calories > Macros > Quality

That's the order.


 

WHY THIS MATTERS FOR YOUR TRAINING

At DRXVE, we run two methods:

The MACHINE 🤖 (Training Method)

  • Builds STRENGTH + ENERGY + ABILITY
  • Increases calorie expenditure
  • Builds lean mass

COMP 🧠 (Nutrition Method)

  • Teaches Macro Lens (how to see food)
  • Teaches LM/FM ratio (how to see your body)
  • Creates systematic deficit

Both methods work together.

The MACHINE increases your calorie burn and builds muscle. COMP ensures you're in a deficit while protecting that muscle.

But COMP starts with the hierarchy:

  1. Calories first
  2. Macros second
  3. Quality third

Not the other way around.


 

COMMON QUESTIONS

Q: Can I eat "dirty" foods and still lose fat?

If you're in a caloric deficit and hitting your macros, yes. But you'll feel like shit, have low energy for training, and be hungry all the time.

Quality matters for performance, satiety, and how you feel. But it can't override the deficit equation.

Q: What about "clean eating" vs IIFYM (If It Fits Your Macros)?

Both work if calories and macros are handled. The debate is a distraction.

Clean eating can work great if you're naturally in a deficit. IIFYM can work great if you track accurately.

The real question: Are you in a deficit? Are you hitting your macros?

Q: Should I count calories forever?

No. You count calories to LEARN the method. Then you earn flexibility.

After 6 months of systematic tracking, you internalize portion sizes, food composition, and calorie density. Then you can maintain without tracking.

But you have to learn it first.

Q: What about metabolic damage or starvation mode?

Your metabolism adapts to caloric restriction—this is real.5 But "starvation mode" where your body stops losing fat is a myth.

The adaptation means you need slightly fewer calories as you lose weight. That's why we recalibrate your targets monthly on your COMP Card.

Q: Does meal timing matter?

For fat loss? Minimally. Total daily calories and macros matter far more than when you eat them.

For performance and satiety? Yes. Eating before training helps performance. Eating protein throughout the day helps muscle retention.

But don't use meal timing as an excuse to ignore total intake.


 

THE BOTTOM LINE

If your #1 goal is dropping body fat:

  1. Get into a caloric deficit (track your food, create 300-500 cal deficit)
  2. Hit your macros (prioritize protein + fiber, optimize carbs/fats for training)
  3. Choose quality foods when you can (better performance, satiety, health)

In that order.

Stop worrying about organic vs conventional if you haven't handled Step 1.

Stop debating grass-fed vs grain-fed if you're not tracking total calories.

Stop avoiding gluten if you're eating 3,000 calories daily.

Handle the hierarchy. Get results.

 


WANT TO LEARN THE COMPLETE METHOD?

This article covers the fundamentals. But there's more to learn:

How to Track Macros Using Chronometer
Set up your tracker correctly and avoid common mistakes.

The Macro Lens - How to See Food Composition
Learn to see what's actually in your food (not just calories).

21-Day STFU & EAT Plan
Free download. Structured 21-day plan to build momentum.

The COMP Method - 6-Stage Nutrition Education
Complete nutrition method taught at DRXVE Training.

GO30 - Experience Both Methods
30 days unlimited. The MACHINE (training) + COMP (nutrition). $197.


 

FOR BODY. FOR FAMILY. FOR LIFE.

THE SAVAGE LANDS 🌴

DRXVE


 

Related Articles:


 

REFERENCES

  1. Strasser B, Spreitzer A, Haber P. Fat loss depends on energy deficit only, independently of the method for weight loss. Obes Facts. 2007;1(1):27-34. PubMed

  2. Strohacker K, McCaffery JM. Rate of weight loss can be predicted by patient characteristics and intervention strategies. J Acad Nutr Diet. 2012 Jan;112(1):75-80. PMC3447534

  3. Halton TL, Hu FB. The effects of high protein diets on thermogenesis, satiety and weight loss: a critical review. J Am Coll Nutr. 2004 Oct;23(5):373-85. PubMed

  4. Calcagno M, Kahleova H, Alwarith J, et al. The Thermic Effect of Food: A Review. J Am Coll Nutr. 2019 Aug;38(6):547-551. PubMed

  5. Redman LM, Heilbronn LK, Martin CK, et al. Impact of calorie restriction on energy metabolism in humans. Exp Gerontol. 2022 May;161:111739. PMC9036397